Should You Replace The Toilet When Remodeling?

Remodeling your home is an enormous financial undertaking. People remodel their homes for various reasons, such as aesthetic enhancement, increasing property value, or fixing up problematic appliances. However, when remodeling, people often question whether to replace their toilet since it is expensive and time-consuming. 

Replacing an old toilet with an ultra-modern version will increase the value of a home. However, when remodeling, it is not critical to replace the toilet if it is less than 15 years old and has no cracks, leaks, or serious problems since the upfront costs will outweigh any future benefits. 

It is unnecessary to replace the toilet when remodeling unless it is old, does not fit in with the bathroom’s aesthetic, or is attempting to increase the value of your home. If your toilet works properly, does not leak water and suits the bathroom’s style, then experts suggest you don’t replace it during remodeling. 

Is It Essential To Replace The Toilet When Remodeling?

Everyone that has remodeled their homes to various degrees will agree that the process is not for the fainthearted or the unprepared, as numerous inevitable challenges are likely to arise.

Avoiding any unnecessary and time-consuming mistakes during the remodeling process requires thorough preparation. While deciding to remodel is an easy step in the process, choosing what to replace is far more difficult. When remodeling a bathroom, homeowners are faced with a thought-provoking choice concerning whether to replace the toilet or not. 

Replacing the toilet in your remodeled bathroom will immediately increase the home’s value. Since the toilet will likely look different from the rest of the bathroom and could be outdated, it is recommended to replace it with an appropriate and modern solution if you aim to increase the home’s value before selling it. 

However, if you are not attempting to increase the value of your house through an extensive remodeling process, then leaving the toilet originally installed is the recommended option. Toilets only need to be replaced every 50 years or when they are not up to modern standards. Old toilets that are cracked, leak, or do not aesthetically match the rest of the bathroom should also be replaced. 

Replacing the toilet during a remodeling process is the homeowner’s choice. The correct solution for your particular situation and home will dictate the necessity of replacing the toilet. Remodeling the bathroom will require a professional to temporarily remove the toilet, which should be re-installed if you are satisfied with its aesthetic, performance, and lifespan. 

I wrote this helpful article about How Do You Fix a Toilet That Is Close To The Wall so you can easily fix a toilet.

Learn More!!!  What Type Of Caulk For Toilet Base?

When Is It Worth It To Replace A Toilet?

Replacing a toilet is an expensive process. Toilets should only be replaced during specific remodeling processes if it is too old or if their water consumption is too high. 

Toilets that don’t meet the above criteria don’t have to be replaced and should instead be repaired or serviced as the costs outweigh any associated benefits. When homeowners replace their toilets during an extensive remodeling process, they expect an average return of more than 100%.

The average return means that homeowners should profit five percent of the toilet’s cost price when the home is sold. However, the profit margin is not guaranteed and will depend on various other issues in the sales process. However, if the toilet is not older than 15 years and has no notable issues, experts note that it will be less expensive to repair. 

While toilets are designed to last for more than 50 years, some start leaking while others are permanently stained before their intended lifespan has lapsed. In addition, some older toilets use excessive water, meaning that it would be better for the environment and your monthly water bill to have it replaced. 

If during your remodeling process, your toilet is too old, leaks, uses too much water, or does not match the aesthetic of the bathroom remodel, it should be replaced. However, most toilets do not fit into the abovementioned categories, meaning they would be more cost-effective, environmentally friendly, and convenient to repair.  

Why You Shouldn’t Replace The Toilet When Remodeling

When remodeling a bathroom, the toilet must be temporarily removed while the tiling, piping, and other appliances occur. 

Temporarily removing the toilet is not a straightforward process and mostly requires the services of a professional. Hiring a professional is costly, meaning not replacing the toilet will dramatically decrease the total costs of the remodeling process. Toilets are amazing inventions, with most being built to function properly for over 50 years. 

If the toilet is properly removed, reset, and stored, there is no justifiable reason to replace it entirely. Suppose you are remodeling the bathroom to improve your family home and not too soon put it on the market. In that case, the costs of installing a new toilet will outweigh any associated benefits. 

Modern toilets will save you money on your monthly water bill, although, to recoup the enormous initial costs will have to stay in the same house for more than a decade. In addition, replacing a toilet will require a professional to redo the surrounding flooring, piping, and sealing, which comes at an enormous cost to any homeowner. 

Learn More!!!  How Do You Fix a Toilet That Is Close To The Wall?

It is unnecessary to replace the toilet when remodeling unless it is more than 15 years old or you want to polish the overall look and aesthetic of your home. However, if your toilet costs you too much for repairs and services, it may be time to replace it. The cost versus reward of replacing your toilet can easily be calculated, with this figure assisting you in your eventual decision. 

When Must You Replace A Toilet?

Toilets should be replaced when constantly repairing it can no longer be financially justified. 

Toilets designed and installed before 2000 do not meet the federally mandated water-per-flush requirements. Older toilets use more than 50% more water each time they are flushed, meaning homeowners can save $100 on yearly water bills. If your toilet is too old and you are not planning to sell the home soon, the toilet should be replaced. 

Moreover, toilets can be faulty and incorrectly installed, requiring constant repairs. If your toilet is becoming increasingly costly to repair or the breakages are becoming more frequent, it makes financial sense to replace it. 

While most toilets function optimally, some leak water due to old age or cracks. Leaking toilets are problematic, time-consuming, and costly for any homeowner. A leaking toilet will waste precious water, damage any surrounding tiles, and create an enormous inconvenience for any homeowner.

Most toilets that leak can be easily repaired; however, if the water flow does not stop, the toilet should be replaced. 

Learn more!!! What Type Of Caulk For Toilet Base?


Replacing your toilet when remodeling is not recommended for most homeowners. When remodeling your bathroom, you should attempt to service or reset the toilet before replacing it, as the associated costs mostly outweigh any known benefits. However, it should be replaced if the toilet does not align with the remodeled aesthetic or look. 

Homeowners remodeling their homes to increase their value before selling them should replace their toilets if it does not match the modernity of the remainder of the bathroom. If your toilet is leaking, consuming too much water, or is outdated, replacing it would be the best option. Replacing the toilet when remodeling may be tempting, for most homeowners, it is completely unnecessary. 

Similar Posts